Air Fryer Grilled Cheese Toastie (Air Fryer Grilled Cheese Sandwich)

air fryer grilled cheese sandwich on board

No ratings yet

This air fryer grilled cheese sandwich is the hot cheese toastie in the air fryer you've been waiting for! Customize the cheese, the bread, and the spread to suit your needs!

Prep Time2

Cook Time10

Total Time12

Course: Main Course

Cuisine: American

Keyword: air fryer cheese toastie, air fryer grilled cheese sandwich

Servings: servings

Calories: 182kcal

Cost: $2

Equipment

1 air fryer

Ingredients

4 slices Bread Sandwich bread of your choice
2 tbsp Mayonnaise Or butter or Country Crock
2 tsp Dijon mustard optional (or Sriracha sauce)
4 slices Cheddar You can just use two slices if you desire less cheese.

Instructions

(If using the Dijon mustard or the sriracha sauce, you will mix it in with the mayo in a small cup before spreading the mayo on the bread.) Spread the mayo on one side of each bread slice. Be sure to reach the edges of the bread.
Place one bread slice (spread facing down) in the air fryer.
Place two slices of cheddar (or just one slice if you are just putting one slice per sandwich).
Place the second piece of bread on top with the spread facing up. (Affix toothpicks to the top slice of bread if you wish to help prevent the sandwich was moving around in the air fryer.)
Cook in air fryer at 375° for five minutes.
Flip and cook another five minutes. Bread should be nice and brown. If cheese is not gooey enough for your liking, cook one more minute. Watch for your desired crispness.

Notes

*You can substitute other types of cheese slices.

Nutrition